Before Shlomo's (Solomon) death an Israelite named Jerobaum was unhappy with Shlomo's rule, attempted some sort of revolt, and then fled to Egypt. When Shlomo died Jerobaum returned and went to speak with Shlomo's heir, Rehobaum. Jerobaum asked him to lighten the tax burden (if you recall Shlomo required a great deal from the Israelites both to build the Temple and his palace), promising eternal support if Rehobaum would only make things a little bit easier for the people. Rehobaum seeks the advice of the elders, who encourage him to accede to Jerobaum's request. Rehobaum then consults his young friends (I like to think of them as the rich kids who's parents never told them "no") who disagree with the elders, advising Rehobaum to tell Jerobaum "My little finger is thicker than my father's loins. My father imposed a heavy yoke on you, and I will add to your yoke; my father flogged you with whips, but I will flog you with scorpions." (1 Kings 12:10-11, JPS translation) Unfortunately, Rehobaum, the new king, who should be trying to consolidate his rule takes the advice of his young friends. Great politician, huh?
Obviously, Jerobaum can't accept this, and the 10 tribes of the north secede (~930 BCE) to form the Kingdom of Israel, leaving Rehobaum in charge of the Kingdom of Yehuda (Judah). At this point several prophecies have come true. Shmuel, when the Israelites originally asked for a king, warned them how oppressive a king would be. Hashem, in response to Shlomo's avodah zara (worship of foreign gods) tells him that his descendants will rule over only one tribe. We see here that both of those things have now come true. From now on there will be two Jewish states: Israel in the north and Yehuda in the south. After the split the two kingdoms spend several decades fighting each other before arriving at some sort of peace agreement.
According to the Tanakh the kingdom of Israel quickly deteriorates into avodah zarah (worship of foreign gods). In class, for example we spoke about King Ahab and his Phoenician wife Jezebel, who persecute those who worship Hashem (the story begins toward the end of the first book of Kings, 1 Kings 18 will give you the idea). According to more traditional measures (military/economic power, for example), Israel is clearly the more powerful and successful of the two kingdoms.
It is during this period that the later prophets, such as Eliyahu HaNavi (Elijah the prophet), become active. The early prophets, such as Shmuel (Samuel) and Natan (Nathan), were part of the leadership structure. In modern terms they provided a sort of balance of power to the kings Shaul (Saul) and David respectively. The later prophets are decidedly outside the government. Eliyahu, as is typical of the later prophets, is actually pursued by Ahab and (especially) Jezebel, who want to kill him in retribution for killing the prophets of Jezebel's foreign gods. We also looked briefly at the episode after Eliyahu flees, in which he is hiding in a cave and Hashem tells him that there will be no more large demonstrations of power (Hashem had just publicly helped Eliyahu prove that Hashem is the one and only God), but Hashem will now be a "soft murmuring sound" (also translated as "a still, small voice", if you want to see the Hebrew it's 1 Kings 19:12). This seems to answer the often asked question, "Why are there no more miracles like we see in the Tanakh?" Do you think Hashem decided to influence the world in a different way, stop actively influencing it completely, or was this simply added later to explain away the lack of big, obvious miracles?
Obviously, Jerobaum can't accept this, and the 10 tribes of the north secede (~930 BCE) to form the Kingdom of Israel, leaving Rehobaum in charge of the Kingdom of Yehuda (Judah). At this point several prophecies have come true. Shmuel, when the Israelites originally asked for a king, warned them how oppressive a king would be. Hashem, in response to Shlomo's avodah zara (worship of foreign gods) tells him that his descendants will rule over only one tribe. We see here that both of those things have now come true. From now on there will be two Jewish states: Israel in the north and Yehuda in the south. After the split the two kingdoms spend several decades fighting each other before arriving at some sort of peace agreement.
After Shlomo there are two Jewish states: Israel in the north and Yehuda in the south |
It is during this period that the later prophets, such as Eliyahu HaNavi (Elijah the prophet), become active. The early prophets, such as Shmuel (Samuel) and Natan (Nathan), were part of the leadership structure. In modern terms they provided a sort of balance of power to the kings Shaul (Saul) and David respectively. The later prophets are decidedly outside the government. Eliyahu, as is typical of the later prophets, is actually pursued by Ahab and (especially) Jezebel, who want to kill him in retribution for killing the prophets of Jezebel's foreign gods. We also looked briefly at the episode after Eliyahu flees, in which he is hiding in a cave and Hashem tells him that there will be no more large demonstrations of power (Hashem had just publicly helped Eliyahu prove that Hashem is the one and only God), but Hashem will now be a "soft murmuring sound" (also translated as "a still, small voice", if you want to see the Hebrew it's 1 Kings 19:12). This seems to answer the often asked question, "Why are there no more miracles like we see in the Tanakh?" Do you think Hashem decided to influence the world in a different way, stop actively influencing it completely, or was this simply added later to explain away the lack of big, obvious miracles?
As we would expect the Kingdom of Israel, who is doing avodah zarah, is eventually punished. The mechanism for their punishment in this case is the Assyrians, a Mesopotamia-based empire who have a resurgence around 800 BCE.
In 722 BCE the Assyrians conquer Israel. Many of the citizens of Israel were deported, in line with Assyrian imperial policy. This destruction and subsequent deportation led to what is known as the 10 lost tribes. As with any area in which there's a war there would certainly have been many people who chose to flee, some of them (if not most) to their southern neighbor, the Kingdom of Judah. As further proof for this phenomenon there is archaeological and historical evidence that the King of Judah at the time, Hezekiah, enlarged the walls of Yerushalayim considerably (the large square-ish part in the picture below), likely in part to accommodate the refugees.
20 years later Hezekiah decided to take advantage of unrest in Mesopotamia (the Assyrian homeland) to throw off the Assyrian yoke and declare independence. Among his preparations he improved the water tunnel to the Gihon spring, which you can see in the picture above. The Assyrians, after dealing with the unrest, arrived to Yehuda and devastated the entire country (such as we see in Lachish, for example). Having destroyed the rest of the country they arrive in 701 BCE to Yerushalayim, which they put to siege (I've recommended to the students several times to read about what it's like to be under siege, for example the relatively recent Siege of Leningrad or even the fictional siege of King's Landing in Game of Thrones, to get a sense of how scary and terrible it is). According to the Tanakh Hashem killed thousands of Assyrian soldiers, causing them to lift the siege and flee back to Mesopotamia. Other sources claim a plague ravaged the Assyrian ranks. Yet others say they left to, once again, deal with unrest in the homeland. All the sources agree Yerushalayim was saved. You can imagine the euphoria in the city as the Assyrians left.
The original city of David (right) and Hezekiah's Wall (left) |
One consequence of the "miraculous" departure of the Assyrian army is that the Yehudans came to believe that Hashem would never allow Yerushalayim, the holy city, to be conquered. Just over a hundred years later the Babylonians (also based in Mesopotamia) were the major power in the region. The King of Yehuda at this time decided to ally with the Egyptians against the Babylonians. It turns out he bet wrong. The ascendant Babylonians arrived to Yehuda and began a siege of Yerushalayim. Despite the prophet Jeremiah's cries to repent and warnings that Yerushalayim would be handed over to the Babylonian army, the King of Yehuda held firm, buoyed by the promises of false prophets (according to the Tanakh, I don't expect I could tell whether a prophet is true or false) and no doubt the memory of the miracle that saved Yerushalayim from the Assyrians. On the ninth of Av (a Hebrew month) the Babylonians destroyed Beit HaMikdash (the Temple); since then this has been a day of mourning for Am Yisrael (Tisha b'Av, the ninth of Av). The elites of Yehuda are sent in exile to Babylon, and after ~600 years living in our homeland in Eretz Yisrael we are sent into Galut Bavel (the Babylonian Exile).
Do you think Am Yisrael deserved this punishment? Is it divine? Is it simply the whim of history? If you heard this about another people, would you expect them to still be around thousands of years later?
I do think Am Yisrael deserved this punishment, although it was incredibly harsh, I believe it served as a good lesson and wake up call to the Israelites. Their belief that Hashem would protect Jerusalem no matter what was essentially too good to be true, and they needed to learn how to fend for themselves. They disobeyed Hashem with avodah zara and they needed to be reminded of their brit with Hashem. However, it is remarkable that they are still around thousands of years later; most African American tribes who were around just a couple hundred years ago are already extinct, so it is amazing that the Jews have persevered through thousands of years of hardship and obstacles.
ReplyDeleteI believe that Hashem chose to create less obvious miracles, because that phase of religion was done. Hashem had clearly proven time and time again with amazing miracles his existence to the Jewish people, and after years of cycling through Avodah Zarah clearly huge miracles were not permanently influencing belief. Maybe it was time for a new era of smaller miracles- just the little things that inspire the population and make life a more beautiful experience rather than huge legendary stories.
ReplyDeleteI have mixed views about whether or not Am Israel deserved this punishment. On one hand, I think that the Israelites being exiled by the Babylonians was a wake up call for them. It showed them how serious HaShem is, and that Avodah Zarah only leads to downfall. I also think it helped them realize how important their land was to them. On the other hand, I think that this punishment was extremely harsh. HaShem gave the Israelites this land. It is very special and holy for them, and now they are being forced to leave. Despite being exiled, along with all of its complications, I think that this event is something that made the Israelites stronger as people. It made us realize how important our land and our values are, and it is an incredible lesson in Jewish History today. It is truly incredible that after all of these years, Judaism, as well as the land of Israel, are still around.
ReplyDeleteIf I heard this about another people, I would never have guessed that they would still be an am thousands of years later! How could we keep our religion alive after it was essentially destroyed!? Thats why our religion is so incredible! The fact that the Asyrians conquered Israel thousands of years ago and we still carry on jewish tradition makes me realize how old and impressive our religion is, especially considering we have endured to keep it alive.
ReplyDeleteI think that at a point the amount of Avodah Zarah can reach to much. God had given the Jews so many chances and they still kept praying to other Gods. So when the Babylonians came and destroyed the 1st temple it almost didn't seem like a surprise. It was bound to happen at some point. Like Marisa said this was a wake up call for the Jews, a much needed one. After this we bonded as a religion and were able to keep our beliefs alive. That's a truly amazing thing so even though the temple was destroyed in a way it was a step in the right direction for the Jews.
ReplyDeleteI think that the change in Am Israel witnessing G-Ds grand gestures in the Tanakh to become just a whisper is one of the reasons why so many Jews don’t believe in G-D. Following World War Two especially, it is evident that some Jews lost faith in G-D because he did nothing to stop the Holocaust. There are various opinions on what G-Ds role plays in our society. I believe that G-D is out there and listening, but can’t really control the major positive or negative things that happen in the world. I think the next question then, is why do we continue to pray for peace if we know it will most likely never happen.
ReplyDeleteI think that because Hashem created so many great miracles and protected Jerusalem before, Am Israel believed that no matter what sins or mistakes they made, Jerusalem would always be protected. I think from a religious standpoint, yes, the Jewish people needed to be exiled in order to realize that Judaism is not just a one way street. G-d will not protect you if you worship other gods. From a non-religious standpoint, I don't think that losing Jerusalem was a punishment as much as I think it was just the fact that the Jews were outnumbered. I tend to side more with the non-religious side, just because it is more practical and because the Babylonians had such as a huge empire at the time. If this happened to another people, I would be very surprised that they have lasted this long and persevered through so many tragic events.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the Jews deserved this punishment, but for all the right reasons. God needed to show the Jews that they can't just do whatever they want and worship other gods but still fall back on Hashem when they need to. By punishing the Jews, it served as a wake up call to show that God will always be there for them but they have to cooperate, too. In addition, the fact that Judaism didn't die out and still is a strong religion today proves that even when God punishes the Jews, He is still watching over to make sure that the punishment has positive long term effects.
ReplyDeleteThe Jewish people screwed up quite a bit with all of the Avodah Zara that they did, but I think that their punishment for this was a bit much this time. The destruction of the Temple was horrible and that is why Jews mourn it the way they do. On a side note, pg 586 in the some Mishkan Tifillalot is the Aleinu which is one of the big prayers for peace and repairing the world. The Aleinu is was put on 586 on purpose so as to remind us that we will always be praying for that perfect world.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the jewish people did deserve this punishment. Without it, jews would not have learned to protect themselves in times of need. Although their devout belief in God and his almighty power is admirable, I believe that this is God's way of slowly pulling out of history, such as was seen in the Tanakh. Although it is a crazy thought to think that after all of our struggles, the jewish people is still around today, we have to give partial credit to ourselves after learning how to deal with enemies.
ReplyDelete