In my previous post I explained the flowering of Jewish culture under Persian rule that resulted in the Babylonian Talmud. Unfortunately, like all periods of prosperity, it didn't last (how's that for upbeat?). The Persians and the Byzantines (the remainder of the Roman Empire based in Constantinople in Asia Minor) spent most of the 6th century in a series of devastating wars. So by the year 600 they were exhausted in every sense of the word, making it very easy for the world's newest superpower to burst onto the scene, and that's exactly what the Arab Muslims did.
The Arab people first show up in written history around the year 900 BCE (meaning, of course, they certainly existed before that), and up until the time of Muhammad were essentially synonymous with what we today call Bedouins, the nomads and semi-nomads who live in the desert. In the early 600s Muhammad was a poor man living in the city of Mecca, a trade hub which housed a stone considered holy by the pagan Arabs (the Kaaba stone). Like most nomads, in Arab culture there is a strong emphasis on family and tribal loyalty, which often leads to bitter rivalries between different families (something that can still be seen in the modern Arab world). So the world Muhammad lived in was full of various tribes in a constant state of semi-warfare.
According to Muslim tradition (and virtually everything we know about Muhammad is based on tradition, rather than historical fact) Muhammad received the Quran over a period of years from the angel Gabriel ("proof", according to Muslims, of its divine origin is the quality of its writing, impossible for an illiterate like Muhammad). He began to preach the teachings of this Quran around Mecca, which was met with disapproval, much like Jesus in Nazareth ("no prophet is welcome in his hometown"), and in 622 Muhammad and his followers fled to Medina, an event known as the Hijra, which represents the beginning of the Muslim calendar. In Medina Muhammad was more successful, and after a number of years his expanded band of followers were able to conquer Mecca. Shortly thereafter Muhammad successfully united all the tribes of the Arab peninsula (which history has shown to be a very big deal, given how rarely the Arabs have been unified since then).
As the Arab-Muslim empire began to expand, Muhammad died, passing on the leadership to a position called the Caliph, which is a combination of spiritual and temporal leader. The first few Caliphs are generally agreed (among Muslims) to have been good leaders (known as the Rashidun), after which accounts start to differ. At any rate the first major dynasty to rule this new (and rapidly expanding empire) was called the Umayyad dynasty. Under the Umayyads the Arab-Muslim Empire reached its greatest extent (in around 750), which is shown below.
Compared to the Roman Empire, which took 1000 years to reach its peak, the Arab-Muslim Empire practically exploded onto the scene, helped along by the weakened state of the Persians and Byzantines. But the Arabs, who were used to living as nomads/semi-nomads, had no experience governing large territories, so the burden/privilege of governance often fell on the same people who had been governing for years, with the Arab conquerors simply cracking the whip (I mean that figuratively, though I'm sure there were literal instances as well). By the time the Abbassid dynasty, which had replaced the Umayyads everywhere except for Spain (more on that in the next post), there were many non-Arab Muslims holding important posts. The Persians, especially, adopted the Arabic script and Muslim religion and mixed them together with Persian culture and governance. It was this milieu that led the Islamic civilization (which it's no longer really accurate to call Arab-Muslim, in my opinion) to the staggering heights it reached at its zenith in the 9th century. For hundreds of years Islam carried the torch of civilization while Europe recovered from the end of the Roman Empire, exemplified by the House of Wisdom built by the Abbassids in their new capital of Baghdad.
So what exactly did these Muslims believe? First of all, they don't see Muhammad as having received anything new. In their view God had given the same message to Abraham, Moses, Elijah, Jesus, etc., but in each instance it was gradually lost and/or corrupted. Therefore, virtually anyone who's considered holy by Jews or early Christians is also holy in Islam. From a Muslim viewpoint Muhammad is simply the last prophet, and this time the message didn't get lost.
The essence of Islam is expressed in five "pillars". The first is a simple declaration of faith; Allah is God and Muhammad is his messenger. The second requires Muslims to pray five times a day. You can actually hear the beautiful call to prayer from our Arab neighbors here at Kibbutz Tzuba (and, truthfully, the call is a lot more beautiful in the middle of the afternoon than it is at 5:30 in the morning). The third requires Muslims to fast during the daylight hours during the entire month of Ramadan (which, compared to the secular calendar, moves each year because the Muslim calendar is lunar, like most non-agricultural peoples). The fourth is the requirement to give charity (2.5% of your savings per year if you have above a certain amount). The final requirement is to complete the Haj, a pilgrimage to Mecca, at least once in your life if you're able.
As you can see, there are quite a few similarities between Muslim and Jewish beliefs. For example, Muslims and Jews both believe in one God, rather than the more complicated trinity worshiped by Christians (I'd like to be clear that Christians still certainly consider themselves monotheists, it's just more theologically complicated). But compared to pagans, all three of the Abrahamic faiths are quite similar, and so when Muslims conquered the world they gave a special status to the "peoples of the book" (Jews and Christians) known as Dhimmi. This status gave people of the book the right to live in Muslim society, though often with additional taxes and restrictions. Speaking very broadly, historically it has been better to be Jewish in a Muslim society than in a Christian one.
The Arab people first show up in written history around the year 900 BCE (meaning, of course, they certainly existed before that), and up until the time of Muhammad were essentially synonymous with what we today call Bedouins, the nomads and semi-nomads who live in the desert. In the early 600s Muhammad was a poor man living in the city of Mecca, a trade hub which housed a stone considered holy by the pagan Arabs (the Kaaba stone). Like most nomads, in Arab culture there is a strong emphasis on family and tribal loyalty, which often leads to bitter rivalries between different families (something that can still be seen in the modern Arab world). So the world Muhammad lived in was full of various tribes in a constant state of semi-warfare.
According to Muslim tradition (and virtually everything we know about Muhammad is based on tradition, rather than historical fact) Muhammad received the Quran over a period of years from the angel Gabriel ("proof", according to Muslims, of its divine origin is the quality of its writing, impossible for an illiterate like Muhammad). He began to preach the teachings of this Quran around Mecca, which was met with disapproval, much like Jesus in Nazareth ("no prophet is welcome in his hometown"), and in 622 Muhammad and his followers fled to Medina, an event known as the Hijra, which represents the beginning of the Muslim calendar. In Medina Muhammad was more successful, and after a number of years his expanded band of followers were able to conquer Mecca. Shortly thereafter Muhammad successfully united all the tribes of the Arab peninsula (which history has shown to be a very big deal, given how rarely the Arabs have been unified since then).
As the Arab-Muslim empire began to expand, Muhammad died, passing on the leadership to a position called the Caliph, which is a combination of spiritual and temporal leader. The first few Caliphs are generally agreed (among Muslims) to have been good leaders (known as the Rashidun), after which accounts start to differ. At any rate the first major dynasty to rule this new (and rapidly expanding empire) was called the Umayyad dynasty. Under the Umayyads the Arab-Muslim Empire reached its greatest extent (in around 750), which is shown below.
stages of Muslim conquest |
So what exactly did these Muslims believe? First of all, they don't see Muhammad as having received anything new. In their view God had given the same message to Abraham, Moses, Elijah, Jesus, etc., but in each instance it was gradually lost and/or corrupted. Therefore, virtually anyone who's considered holy by Jews or early Christians is also holy in Islam. From a Muslim viewpoint Muhammad is simply the last prophet, and this time the message didn't get lost.
The essence of Islam is expressed in five "pillars". The first is a simple declaration of faith; Allah is God and Muhammad is his messenger. The second requires Muslims to pray five times a day. You can actually hear the beautiful call to prayer from our Arab neighbors here at Kibbutz Tzuba (and, truthfully, the call is a lot more beautiful in the middle of the afternoon than it is at 5:30 in the morning). The third requires Muslims to fast during the daylight hours during the entire month of Ramadan (which, compared to the secular calendar, moves each year because the Muslim calendar is lunar, like most non-agricultural peoples). The fourth is the requirement to give charity (2.5% of your savings per year if you have above a certain amount). The final requirement is to complete the Haj, a pilgrimage to Mecca, at least once in your life if you're able.
As you can see, there are quite a few similarities between Muslim and Jewish beliefs. For example, Muslims and Jews both believe in one God, rather than the more complicated trinity worshiped by Christians (I'd like to be clear that Christians still certainly consider themselves monotheists, it's just more theologically complicated). But compared to pagans, all three of the Abrahamic faiths are quite similar, and so when Muslims conquered the world they gave a special status to the "peoples of the book" (Jews and Christians) known as Dhimmi. This status gave people of the book the right to live in Muslim society, though often with additional taxes and restrictions. Speaking very broadly, historically it has been better to be Jewish in a Muslim society than in a Christian one.
I really enjoyed the tiyul yesterday to the Arab villages, and not only because of the amazing food. I was really interested in what the woman we spoke to and the Imam had to say about their religion. My favorite thing about the Islam religion is that they believe that our Torah and the Christian New Testament are still of the same place. I like the connection we can make between all three prayer books. In a way, even though our religions are very different, it shows us how similar they all are at the core.
ReplyDeleteI thought that the fact that muslims believe both judaism's and christianity's profits is very interesting. It really emphasizes how similar all three religions are, and yet countless religious wars have been fought, and some may argue that they are still going on today. After learning this about Islam, as well as listening to the Imam on the tiyul, I now know more about the religion and am able to create politically correct opinions about it, rather than learning from a biased source.
ReplyDeleteAfter yesterday's tiyul, I have a very different perspective on Islam. I entered the mosque with an open mind, and was pleased that the speaker did a really good job of relieving many of the common prejudices against Muslims. It was really interesting to learn that the Islam religion is very similar to Judaism, even more so than Christianity. I am really glad that EIE has given me the opportunity to learn about other religions; this knowledge has given me a new perspective on Judaism and I feel that I am learning a lot.
ReplyDeleteI loved the tiyul yesterday. For one thing the food was amazing. More than that, I really enjoyed listening to the woman speak about Islam. It brought a lot of clarity to my understanding of the religion. It made me notice how very little I understand about Islam compared to Christianity and Judaism. At home we are relatively uneducated about this religion which is strange to me considering it is such an important religion and so politically tied today. Hearing about the core religious beliefs of Islam helps to clarify the confusion between what is religion and what is political.
ReplyDeleteI really appreciated yesterdays Tiyul. It was really nice to hear about Islam from someone who converted to the religion as well as from the Imam. I walked out of the mosque with a very different perspective of Islam than what I started with. I think that other people should have the opportunity to hear first hand the actual religion, and not just make judgements based off of what the media says. I also think that it is very respectful that Muslims still consider the other leaders as profits in their religion. I am so glad that I was able to gain a new perspective on the religion!
ReplyDeleteI also really enjoyed learning about Islam. I had learned the basics of the religion and its history in school, but going to a mosque and experiencing it all was much more meaningful. To me, the coolest part was learning about how similar Islam and Judaism are. Like you said, we do have theological similarities, as well as similarities in the way we practice our religions. And the product of that, relatively peaceful and mature relations between Muslims and Jews, makes much more sense. We're so similar in so many ways, and I have so much more respect for Islam because of what we learned.
ReplyDeleteI loved our tiyul yesterday too, and found it so interesting learning about islam. I absolutely agree with you that it is hader to be jewish in a Christian society than in a muslim society. The surrouding belief in Christian faith can make it harder to be jewish than it would be in a monotheistic based religion
ReplyDeleteIslam is a very interesting religion. Something that caught my attention was that they believe in all of our prophets and writings except that they think overtime it was corrupted by human hands. To me I took that as Judaism and Christianity are invalid and that Islam is the only true religion. I obviously don't agree with this. One thing I would have liked to a address more was the writings in the Quran because there are writings in the Quran that are otherwise violent and unkind to other people. She kept talking about how the extremists don't truly know anything about Islam in it's original form but if you don't accept the fact that the Quran has violent aspects to it, aren't you not accepting it either?
ReplyDeleteOur tiyul to the Arab villages was extremely enjoyable and fulfilling both literally and mentally. I learned an extreme amount of information regarding Islam which I was unaware of before. I found that what both the woman speaker and the Imam said was very interesting, in particular, how Islam believes that the Torah as well as the Christian Bible are both valid and holy, but not used by their religion. However, this connection demonstrates not only the ancient roots of three significant religions, but also the ability for other religions to acknowledge the scriptures and words of different faiths. In a sense, even if it may seem that the religions that make up our world are extremely unalike, there is a foundation of connection which stems within all beliefs.
ReplyDeleteI think that the Tiyul yesterday was very interesting. I loved hearing how different the religion is compared to Judaism even though it still believes in the past prophets, such as Abraham. Also I find it interesting that both Judaism and Christianity have the same basis, but have both gone off course overtime. The Muslims, Islam fills this gap and is the right middle way. I still have an unanswered question that I hope we will adress in class. Does Islam believe in the Old Testament until Muhammad came along? I hope that we can keep learning about other religions.
ReplyDeleteI thought that yesterday's tiyul was really fun and cool. I personally love learning about other religions and how they interact with each other. Islam's ideas about the bible are very interesting because they acknowledge that what we believe is holy used to be holy according to them, but now has been corrupted by human hand and I actually agree with that to a certain extent. Certain parts of the bible have definitely been corrupted by human hands are no longer holy.
ReplyDeleteAfter learning about Islam, first-hand from an Imam who has spent a great deal of time studying the roots of the religion I have a very different view on the religion. Particularly I found it interesting that Islam recognizes all other prophets as being prophets. I agree that it is likely that aspects of religion have been corrupted over time, just as extremist muslim groups use political interest to corrupt the way we view Islam.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed the Tiyul and learning about Islam. The part of the conversation in the mosque that stood out to me is how often the idea that Islam is completely different than it's portrayal in the media was stressed. It made me step back and think about how easy it is to judge any religion based on extremists, and it was interesting to learn that these people aren't actually following the ideals of Islam. Going along with this, it was interesting to learn that different terrorist groups are solely politically motivated because people tend to make assumptions that it correlates completely with the ideology of their religion.
ReplyDeleteI truly enjoyed our Tiyul about the Muslim Culture the other day. First of all, I thought that it was so cool that our parents were able to join us, and see what our Tiyulim experiences were like. Second of all, I thought that being able to be in a Mosque, and talk to a woman who has converted to Islam was so interesting. It was really cool to hear all about her journey and her views on the culture. It was also really interesting to talk to the head of the Mosque and hear about his views, both political and religious. A lot of what he was saying was that the media portrays the religion as so much worse than it is, which made me think a lot about the culture today, and how quick we are to judge others without knowing the full story.
ReplyDelete